• Rules & procedures
    • Dispute types and process
    • Hearings and mediation
    • Rules of the Sports Tribunal
    • Costs
    • Legal assistance
    • Appeal a Tribunal decision
  • Decisions
    • All Decisions
    • Results
  • News
  • Resources
    • Guide to the Sports Tribunal
    • Sports Tribunal Annual Reports
    • Independent Reports
    • Links
    • Forms / Proceeding Forms
    • Transparency Statement
  • About us
    • About the Sports Tribunal
    • Members of the Tribunal
    • Registrar of the Sports Tribunal
    • History
    • FAQ
  • Contact

Decisions

Find the latest Tribunal decisions. You may also be interested in the Results of decisions.

Find Decisions

Latest decisions

217

cases

Expand all

Michael Bias v Cycling New Zealand

06/19 · Decision 17 July 2019

Overview:

Non-selection appeal - 2019 BMX World Championships - Cycling New Zealand had applied new selection criteria to riders, and determined that no male BMX riders would be selected - Tribunal found that the legal position was clear and that it should only intervene if there was no basis or justification... for the selectors' decision - new selection regulations had made subjective appraisals clear - the Tribunal expressed concern at the athlete's and sport's future, but found nothing which suggested that the selectors had misunderstood or misapplied the requirements of the procedure - the selectors had considered a multitude of things and there had been an exhaustive inquiry by the Selection Ombudsman - appeal dismissed

Decision
PDF, 103 KB
Media Release
PDF, 124 KB

Non anti-doping case · Cycling · 18 July 2019

Drug Free Sport New Zealand v Hinewai Pouwhare-Anderson

03/19 · Decision 12 July 2019

Overview:

Anti-doping - Powerlifter based in Palmerston North tested positive for clenbuterol in an in-competition test - provisionally suspended without opposition - admitted violation of the Sports Anti-Doping Rules 2019 (SADR) and expressed reluctance to be involved in the proceedings - Tribunal considered... that an appropriate sanction was four years of ineligibility, which it noted was an extraordinary sanction - backdated to date of the test to account for the athlete's timely admission of the violation - this meant the athlete is ineligible to participate in competitive sport until 13 April 2023

Decision
PDF, 144 KB
Media Release
PDF, 128 KB
Provisional Suspension Order
PDF, 125 KB

Anti-doping case · Powerlifting · 15 July 2019

KL v Table Tennis New Zealand

05/19 · Decision 1 July 2019

Overview:

Non-selection appeal – 2019 Oceania Junior Table Tennis Championships – appellant initially selected for NZ Cadet (U15) Girls’ team but removed for failure to meet certain conditions – appellant submitted Table Tennis NZ acted unfairly or unreasonably in removing her from team – Tribunal found... Table Tennis NZ had acted unreasonably and ordered Appellant be restored to team.

Media release
PDF, 120 KB
Decision
PDF, 410 KB

Non anti-doping case · Table Tennis · 3 July 2019

Drug Free Sport New Zealand v XYZ (Sanction)

12/18 · Decision 3 April 2019

Overview:

Anti-doping - Medsafe investigation into NZ Clenbuterol - XYZ a member of local surf life saving and golf clubs - admitted possession and use of anabolic steroids clenbuterol and dianabol - non-specified substances prohibited at all times - no significant fault or negligence not established - Tribunal... commented on utility and fairness of extending jurisdiction of the Sports Anti-Doping Rules to recreational athletes - Tribunal determined that XYZ should receive 6 months credit for delay in bringing the proceedings, and a further 6 months for timely admission - Tribunal imposed a 2 year period of ineligibility starting 3 October 2018 - accounting for the credits awarded, this means XYZ is ineligible to participate in sport until 3 October 2019 - continued name suppression imposed due to this being a test case on the application of SADR to recreational athletes

Decision on sanction
PDF, 255 KB
Media release on sanction
PDF, 107 KB

Anti-doping case · Swimming · 4 April 2019

Drug Free Sport New Zealand v XYZ

12/18 · Decision 4 March 2019

Overview:

Anti-doping - Medsafe investigation into NZ Clenbuterol - XYZ a member of local surf lifesaving and golf clubs - possession and use of clenbuterol and dianabol - non-specified substances prohibited at all times - admitted violations - provisionally suspended without opposition - sanction to follow submissions...

Decision
PDF, 268 KB
Media Release
PDF, 125 KB
Provisional Suspension Order
PDF, 125 KB

Anti-doping case · Rugby League · 5 March 2019

Show more

  • FAQ
  • Contact us
  • © 2019 Sports Tribunal of New Zealand
  • •Privacy & Copyright