X v Motorcycling NZ (No. 2) (ST 17/26)

X v Motorcycling NZ (No. 2) (ST 17/26)

Appeal against MNZ Judiciary Committee (JC) decision – junior motocross – interference by Y when overtaking X – interpretation of MOMS r. 6.10 – standing – Tribunal found no breach of natural justice – Tribunal found 10 second time penalty JC applied was not available under MOMS r. 6.10 and JC acted outside its powers – penalty inappropriate as it departed from an established sporting practice in motocross – appeal allowed – 10s time penalty set aside – in substitution, one place relegation imposed on Y