Decisions

  • Anon v NZCPA

    Decision on application for costs.

    Read more

  • Anon v New Zealand Canoe Polo Association (08/2023)

    Appeal of NZCPA decision – disciplinary process – decision increased sanction from original decision – denial of natural justice – no opportunity to test inculpatory evidence – stood down from Oceania Champs – supervision period of one year – sanction excessive and disproportionate

    Read more

  • Drug Free Sport New Zealand (DFSNZ) v Anon 01/2023 (Costs)

    Decision on application for costs.

    Read more

  • DFSNZ v Anon

    Six-month period of ineligibility imposed on recreational athlete for unintentional ingestion of a prohibited substance with no significant fault or negligence.

    Read more

  • Drug Free Sport New Zealand v Anon 01/2023

    Anti-doping – golf – presence of and use or attempted use of prohibited substance SARMS – ostarine – in-competition test – adverse analytical finding – defended hearing – Tribunal found unintentional ingestion – no significant fault – recreational athlete – did not have to prove source – Tribunal imposed six month sanction – sanction backdated…

    Read more

  • Drug Free Sport New Zealand v Hinewai Hausman

    Anti-doping – powerlifting – presence of and use or attempted use of prohibited substance Anabolic agents – previously suspended- DFSNZ entitled to continue to test – adverse analytical finding – admitted violations – accepted sanction – no hearing – athlete has retired from sport – eight-year sanction available to the Tribunal – Tribunal exercised discretion…

    Read more

  • Drug Free Sport New Zealand v Vaibhav Sharma

    Anti-doping – rugby – possession of and use or attempted use of prohibited substance Anabolic agents – Customs interception of parcel –accepted immediate provisional suspension – denied charges – hearing – burden of proof on DFSNZ– evidence supporting DFSNZ position – name, address and phone number on parcel – Tribunal comfortably satisfied – Tribunal agreed…

    Read more

  • Tommy Taylor v King’s College

    Dispute – College rugby – parties agreed to bring dispute over whether a schoolboy was eligible for selection to the First XV to the Tribunal for determination – decision made on the papers – oral decision – reasons for the decision – the student transferred schools for reasons other than rugby – the student had…

    Read more

  • Drug Free Sport New Zealand v William Morunga

    Application for reconsideration of periods of ineligibility under SADR 19.3- no dispute over outcome applied for – DFSNZ submit for re-sanction – matter decided on the papers – doctrine of Lex Mitior considered – examination of whether it is open and appropriate for the Tribunal to grant the application – examination of rules 10.2.4.1, 10.9.2…

    Read more

  • Central United Football Club Incorporated and Northern Region Federation

    Dispute – regional football – parties agreed to bring dispute over non-promotion of football club to Tribunal for determination – hearing held  – competition regulations provide for promotion for winning team – Central won League One and earned promotion – Federation denied promotion due to a Memorandum of Understanding – examination of meaning of regulations…

    Read more